Please fill out at least one field before submitting this form.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Detailed Case Information - CV16-02415

Case Description: CV16-02415 - SHIRLEY LOVELACE VS HARVARD APARTMENTS, ETAL (D15)

Filing Date: 11/23/2016

Case Type: SF - PREMISES LIABILITY

Status: Case Disposed

Printer Friendly Version

Case Parties - Click to expand

Case Parties

Seq No. Type Name
1 JUDG - Judge HARDY, DAVID A.
2 ATTY - Attorney Throop, Esq, Julie McGrath
3 DEFT - Defendant HARVARD APARTMENTS,
4 DEFT - Defendant JACOB J. & GERALDINE V. FITZPATRICK TRUST,
5 ATTY - Attorney Friedman, Esq., Terry A.
6 PLTF - Plaintiff LOVELACE, SHIRLEY ANN
8 ATTY - Attorney Hanlon, Esq., Carrie McCrea
10 ATTY - Attorney Selim, Esq, Taylor G.
11 ATTY - Attorney Harper, Esq., James E.
12 ATTY - Attorney Ekins, Esq., Diana Michelle

Cross Reference Number(s) - Click to expand

Reference Numbers

No Cross Reference Numbers Available

Event Information - Click to expand

Event Information

Date/Time Hearing Judge Event Description Outcome
1. 09/30/2019 at 1:00 PM Honorable DAVID HARDY H852 - TRIAL - JURY
D865 - Vacated - Settled filed on: 04/19/2019
Extra Text: STIPULATION AND ORDER FOR DISMISSAL ENTERED
2. 09/09/2019 at 1:00 PM Honorable DAVID HARDY H852 - TRIAL - JURY
D870 - Vacated - Stipulation & Ord filed on: 03/30/2018
Extra Text: TO BE RESET BY COUNSEL WITHIN 10 DAYS
3. 08/30/2019 at 10:00 AM Honorable DAVID HARDY H756 - PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE
D865 - Vacated - Settled filed on: 04/19/2019
Extra Text: STIPULATION AND ORDER FOR DISMISSAL ENTERED
4. 08/08/2019 at 3:30 PM Honorable DAVID HARDY H756 - PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE
D870 - Vacated - Stipulation & Ord filed on: 03/30/2018
Extra Text: TO BE RESET BY COUNSEL WITHIN 10 DAYS
5. 03/04/2019 at 1:00 PM Honorable DAVID HARDY H852 - TRIAL - JURY
D843 - Vacated-to be reset filed on: 10/15/2018
Extra Text: VACATED BY STIPULATION AND ORDER FILED 10/15
6. 02/05/2019 at 3:30 PM Honorable DAVID HARDY H756 - PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE
D843 - Vacated-to be reset filed on: 10/15/2018
Extra Text: VACATED BY STIPULATION AND ORDER FILED 10/15
7. 05/14/2018 at 9:00 AM Honorable DAVID HARDY H852 - TRIAL - JURY
D843 - Vacated-to be reset filed on: 02/13/2018
Extra Text: TRIAL AND PTC TO BE RESET PURSUANT TO STIPULATION AND ORDER FILED 2/13
8. 04/26/2018 at 3:00 PM Honorable DAVID HARDY H756 - PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE
D843 - Vacated-to be reset filed on: 02/13/2018
Extra Text: TRIAL AND PTC TO BE RESET PURSUANT TO STIPULATION AND ORDER FILED 2/13
9. 05/15/2017 at 4:30 PM Honorable DAVID HARDY H185 - CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE
D870 - Vacated - Stipulation & Ord filed on: 03/22/2017
Extra Text: EARLY SCHEDULING CONFERENCE - LIKELY TO VACATE

Docket Entry Information - Click to expand

Docket Entry Information

Docket Description Date Filed Extra Text
1. CHECK - **Trust Disbursement 02/26/2024 Extra Text: A Disbursement of $320.00 on Check Number 16143
2. PAYVD - **Payment Voided 02/22/2024 Extra Text: Receipt Number DCDC734883 has been voided.
3. CHKVO - **Trust Check Voided 02/22/2024 Extra Text: Check Number 15873 for $320.00 has been Voided.
4. CHECK - **Trust Disbursement 01/23/2024 Extra Text: A Disbursement of $320.00 on Check Number 15873
5. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/16/2024 Extra Text: Transaction 10100453 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-16-2024:15:45:26
6. 2990 - Ord Return of Jury Fees 01/16/2024 Extra Text: Transaction 10100437 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-16-2024:15:43:39
7. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 04/19/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7229365 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 04-19-2019:14:53:27
8. F120 - Stipulated Dismissal 04/19/2019 Extra Text:
9. 3990 - Stip & Ord Dismiss W/Prejudice 04/19/2019 Extra Text: OF CASE - Transaction 7229360 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 04-19-2019:14:52:29
10. 2540 - Notice of Entry of Ord 01/07/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7053678 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-07-2019:10:33:22
11. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/07/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7053679 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-07-2019:10:34:14
12. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/11/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 7017609 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-11-2018:10:47:59
13. 3980 - Stip and Order... 12/11/2018 Extra Text: STIPULATED DISCOVERY PLAN AND ORDER - Transaction 7017601 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-11-2018:10:46:57
14. 2610 - Notice ... 12/03/2018 Extra Text: NOTICE OF ASSOCIATION OF COUNSEL (DIANA ELKINS ESQ) - Transaction 7003339 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 12-03-2018:15:35:19
15. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/03/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 7003881 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-03-2018:15:36:40
16. 2582 - Notice of Taking Deposition 11/14/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6975919 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 11-14-2018:11:50:50
17. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 11/14/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6975924 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 11-14-2018:11:51:53
18. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 11/14/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6975930 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 11-14-2018:11:55:51
19. 1120 - Amended ... 11/14/2018 Extra Text: FIRST AMENDED NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION - Transaction 6975925 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 11-14-2018:11:52:57
20. 1250E - Application for Setting eFile 11/13/2018 Extra Text: JURY TRIAL 9/30/19, PTC 8/30/19 - Transaction 6973492 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 11-13-2018:11:15:08
21. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 11/13/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6973498 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 11-13-2018:11:16:25
22. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 11/08/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6969728 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 11-08-2018:15:46:20
23. 2605 - Notice to Set 11/08/2018 Extra Text: 11/13/18 AT 11:00AM - Transaction 6969321 - Approved By: PMSEWELL : 11-08-2018:15:44:01
24. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 10/15/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6928816 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 10-15-2018:14:52:25
25. 4030 - Stip & Ord Continue Trial 10/15/2018 Extra Text: WILL ALL AND RESET WITHIN 10 DAYS - Transaction 6928789 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 10-15-2018:14:48:59
26. COC - Evidence Chain of Custody Form 09/11/2018 Extra Text:
27. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 09/11/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6872355 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 09-11-2018:07:35:39
28. 1610 - Disclosure of Expert Witness 09/10/2018 Extra Text: Exhibit 5 is a CD with photographs and is being hand-delivered to attach to this pleading. - Transaction 6872052 - Approved By: SWILLIAM : 09-11-2018:07:34:39
29. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 09/06/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6867393 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 09-06-2018:16:14:19
30. 1610 - Disclosure of Expert Witness 09/06/2018 Extra Text: PLAINTIFFF'S DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESS JUSTIN R. BRINK - Transaction 6867224 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 09-06-2018:16:13:03
31. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 08/27/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6850705 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-27-2018:16:05:37
32. 2582 - Notice of Taking Deposition 08/27/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6850195 - Approved By: JAPARICI : 08-27-2018:16:04:37
33. 2540 - Notice of Entry of Ord 05/29/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6701992 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-29-2018:15:59:42
34. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 05/29/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6702022 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-29-2018:16:02:44
35. 3915 - Scheduling Order 05/17/2018 Extra Text: STIPULATED DISCOVERY PLAN AND ORDER - Transaction 6684714 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-17-2018:11:36:21
36. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 05/17/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6684718 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-17-2018:11:37:17
37. 2605 - Notice to Set 05/02/2018 Extra Text: NOTICE TO SET TRIAL, INITIAL MANDATORY PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE, PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE - Transaction 6658371 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 05-02-2018:09:49:23
38. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 05/02/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6658469 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-02-2018:09:50:33
39. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 05/02/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6658651 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-02-2018:10:33:04
40. 1250E - Application for Setting eFile 05/02/2018 Extra Text: RESETTING TRAIL 3/4/19, PTC 2/5/19, VACATED PREVIOUS SETTING - Transaction 6658642 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-02-2018:10:32:14
41. 2540 - Notice of Entry of Ord 04/21/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6641531 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 04-21-2018:11:08:35
42. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 04/21/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6641532 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 04-21-2018:11:09:34
43. 4030 - Stip & Ord Continue Trial 03/30/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6605160 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-30-2018:13:08:46
44. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/30/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6605173 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-30-2018:13:10:32
45. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/20/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6586349 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-20-2018:13:50:14
46. 2605 - Notice to Set 03/20/2018 Extra Text: NOTICE TO SET TRIAL, INITIAL MANDATORY PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE AND NOTICE OF EARLY CASE CONFERENCE - Transaction 6586212 - Approved By: CVERA : 03-20-2018:13:48:09
47. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/12/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6572549 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-12-2018:14:20:51
48. 1250E - Application for Setting eFile 03/12/2018 Extra Text: JURY TRIAL 9/9/19, PTC 8/8/19 - Transaction 6572545 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-12-2018:14:20:02
49. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 02/20/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6540943 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-20-2018:17:00:07
50. 2540 - Notice of Entry of Ord 02/20/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6539787 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-20-2018:13:42:04
51. 2605 - Notice to Set 02/20/2018 Extra Text: NOTICE TO SET TRIAL, INITIAL MANDATORY PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE, PRETRIAL CONFERENCE AND NOTICE OF EARLY CASE CONFERENCE - 03/12/2018 @ 2:00 PM - Transaction 6540572 - Approved By: SWILLIAM : 02-20-2018:16:59:05
52. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 02/20/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6539789 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-20-2018:13:43:04
53. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 02/13/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6528861 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-13-2018:08:43:22
54. 4030 - Stip & Ord Continue Trial 02/13/2018 Extra Text: AND ALL DISCOVERY DATES - Transaction 6528857 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-13-2018:08:42:32
55. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/12/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6478693 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-12-2018:08:35:20
56. 2540 - Notice of Entry of Ord 01/12/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6478690 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-12-2018:08:34:30
57. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/05/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6467815 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-05-2018:11:05:16
58. 3980 - Stip and Order... 01/05/2018 Extra Text: TO EXTEND EXPERT AND DISCOVERY DEADLINE - Transaction 6467811 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-05-2018:11:04:17
59. 4075 - Substitution of Counsel 12/15/2017 Extra Text: TAYLOR G. SELIM, ESQ IN PLACE OF KENNETH E. GOATES / DEFT HARVARD APARTMENTS AND JACOB & GERALDINE FITZPATRICK TRUST - Transaction 6441655 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 12-15-2017:14:51:52
60. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/15/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6441736 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-15-2017:14:52:47
61. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/07/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6428108 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-07-2017:11:47:09
62. 2610 - Notice ... 12/07/2017 Extra Text: Notice of Association of Counsel - TAYLOR SELIM, ESQ FOR DEFTS - Transaction 6427944 - Approved By: SWILLIAM : 12-07-2017:11:46:10
63. 2610 - Notice ... 05/16/2017 Extra Text: AMENDED NOTICE OF SITE INSPECTION - 6/14/17 AT 11:00AM - Transaction 6102632 - Approved By: PMSEWELL : 05-16-2017:13:53:52
64. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 05/16/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6102748 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-16-2017:13:54:55
65. 2610 - Notice ... 03/29/2017 Extra Text: NOTICE OF SITE INSPECTION - 4/26/17 @1:30 - Transaction 6022147 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 03-29-2017:09:11:28
66. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/29/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6022152 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-29-2017:09:12:30
67. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/25/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6017428 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-25-2017:11:09:49
68. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/25/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6017397 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-25-2017:08:28:18
69. 2540 - Notice of Entry of Ord 03/25/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6017395 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-25-2017:08:27:27
70. 2540 - Notice of Entry of Ord 03/25/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6017427 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-25-2017:11:08:59
71. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/22/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6011397 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-22-2017:08:49:00
72. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/22/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6011391 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-22-2017:08:48:37
73. 3915 - Scheduling Order 03/22/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6011380 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-22-2017:08:47:38
74. 3980 - Stip and Order... 03/22/2017 Extra Text: TO VACATE EARLY SCHEDULING CONFERENCE - Transaction 6011376 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-22-2017:08:46:54
75. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/21/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6008791 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-21-2017:08:33:11
76. 1835 - Joint Case Conference Report 03/21/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6008732 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 03-21-2017:08:32:12
77. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/16/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6000223 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-16-2017:09:16:54
78. 1250E - Application for Setting eFile 03/16/2017 Extra Text: ESC 5/15/17, PTC 4/26/18, JURY TRIAL 5/14/18 - Transaction 6000221 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-16-2017:09:16:04
79. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 02/08/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5942043 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-08-2017:16:13:22
80. 2540 - Notice of Entry of Ord 02/08/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5942010 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-08-2017:16:05:17
81. 3696 - Pre-Trial Order 02/08/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5941824 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-08-2017:15:34:55
82. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 02/08/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5941834 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-08-2017:15:36:10
83. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 02/08/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5942014 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-08-2017:16:08:06
84. 2605 - Notice to Set 02/08/2017 Extra Text: NOTICE TO SET TRIAL, INITIAL MANDATORY PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE, PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE AND NOTICE OF EARLY CASE CONFERENCE 3/16/17 @9:00 - Transaction 5941878 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 02-08-2017:16:12:17
85. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 02/07/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5937524 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-07-2017:08:57:57
86. A120 - Exemption from Arbitration 02/07/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5937504 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-07-2017:08:55:59
87. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/20/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5908494 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-20-2017:13:51:26
88. 3840 - Request Exemption Arbitration 01/20/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5908449 - Approved By: PMSEWELL : 01-20-2017:13:50:12
89. JF - **First Day Jury Fees Deposit 01/12/2017 Extra Text: Bond ID: JF-17-00017; Total Bond Amount: $320.00. Bond Code, JF, Receipted for: SITE DEFINED TRUST DEPOSIT, on 12-JAN-2017 in the amount of $320.00 on case ID CV16-02415.
90. 1580 - Demand for Jury 01/12/2017 Extra Text: DEFTS-HARVARD APARTMENTS, JACOB & GERALDINE FITZPATRICK TRUST
91. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/04/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5883970 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-04-2017:14:12:33
92. 1817 - Initial Appear. Fee Disclosure 01/04/2017 Extra Text: Initial Appearence Fee Disclosure - Transaction 5883857 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 01-04-2017:14:11:34
93. $DEFT - $Addl Def/Answer - Prty/Appear 01/04/2017 Extra Text: JACOB & GERALDINE FITZPATRICK TRUST - Transaction 5883857 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 01-04-2017:14:11:34
94. $1560 - $Def 1st Appearance - CV 01/04/2017 Extra Text: HARVARD APARTMENTS - Transaction 5883857 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 01-04-2017:14:11:34
95. 1130 - Answer ... 01/04/2017 Extra Text: Answer to Plaintiff's Complaint - Transaction 5883857 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 01-04-2017:14:11:34
96. PAYRC - **Payment Receipted 01/04/2017 Extra Text: A Payment of $243.00 was made on receipt DCDC562308.
97. 4085 - Summons Filed 12/28/2016 Extra Text: 12/18/16 GERALDINE FITZPATRICK - Transaction 5875099 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 12-28-2016:15:13:59
98. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/28/2016 Extra Text: Transaction 5875165 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-28-2016:15:15:21
99. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/27/2016 Extra Text: Transaction 5873504 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-27-2016:16:56:49
100. 4085 - Summons Filed 12/27/2016 Extra Text: SERVED TRACY CHAPMAN MGR OBO HARVARD APTS - 12-21-16 AT 2:14 PM - Transaction 5873425 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 12-27-2016:16:55:55
101. 4090 - ** Summons Issued 12/12/2016 Extra Text:
102. PAYRC - **Payment Receipted 11/23/2016 Extra Text: A Payment of $260.00 was made on receipt DCDC558872.
103. $1425 - $Complaint - Civil 11/23/2016 Extra Text: Transaction 5821275 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 11-23-2016:11:20:19
The District Court is comprised of 16 departments. Each Judge sits in a differently numbered Department. When a Judge leaves service, the new Judge's name replaces the former Judge's name on all matters pending and previously closed in that department. This change will not reflect that a previous sitting Judge presided over a matter.