| Case Description: | CV25-02319 - LAWRENCE GARVEY ETAL VS CLUB TAHOE ETAL (ARB) |
| Filing Date: | 09/25/2025 |
| Case Type: | CO - OTHER CONTRACTS/ACCT/JUDG |
| Status: | Pending Inactive |
| Case Cross Reference Cross Reference Number |
| No Cross Reference Numbers Available |
| Case Parties | ||
| Seq | Type | Name |
| 1 | JUDG - Judge | FREEMAN, SCOTT N. |
| 2 | PLTF - Plaintiff | GARVEY, LAWRENCE |
| 3 | PLTF - Plaintiff | PAYTON, ROBERT |
| 4 | ATTY - Attorney | Haskin, Esq., Richard E. |
| 5 | ATTY - Attorney | Wedderspoon, Esq., Madison G. |
| 6 | DEFT - Defendant | PEARL, MARC |
| 7 | DEFT - Defendant | CLUB TAHOE RESORT OWNERS ASSOCIATION, |
| 8 | DEFT - Defendant | WILSON, KEITH |
| 9 | DEFT - Defendant | DEALBA, GLORIA |
| 10 | DEFT - Defendant | WALL, DONALD |
| 11 | DEFT - Defendant | VERMELTOORT, ROBERT |
| 12 | DEFT - Defendant | BECKER, CHRISTINA |
| 13 | DEFT - Defendant | OGDEN, KEITH |
| 14 | ATTY - Attorney | Selert, Esq., Whitney J. |
| 15 | ATTY - Attorney | Padilla, Esq., Jorge |
| 16 | ATTY - Attorney | Lee, Esq., Marcus J. |
| Event Information | |||
| Date/Time | Hearing Judge | Event Description | Outcome |
| 04/01/2026 at 11:00 AM | Honorable SCOTT FREEMAN | H640 - ORAL ARGUMENTS |
- filed on: Extra Text: |
| 03/10/2026 at 9:08 PM | Honorable SCOTT FREEMAN | S1 - Request for Submission |
S200 - Request for Submission Complet filed on: 03/13/2026 Extra Text: Order setting hearing filed 03/13/26 |
| 03/04/2026 at 12:58 PM | Honorable SCOTT FREEMAN | S1 - Request for Submission |
S200 - Request for Submission Complet filed on: 03/17/2026 Extra Text: Order Granted 03/16/26 |
| 02/24/2026 at 2:24 PM | Honorable SCOTT FREEMAN | S1 - Request for Submission |
S200 - Request for Submission Complet filed on: 03/13/2026 Extra Text: Order setting hearing filed 03/13/26 |
| 02/17/2026 at 12:42 PM | Honorable SCOTT FREEMAN | S1 - Request for Submission |
S200 - Request for Submission Complet filed on: 03/13/2026 Extra Text: Order setting hearing filed 03/13/26 |
| 02/04/2026 at 4:08 PM | Honorable SCOTT FREEMAN | S1 - Request for Submission |
S200 - Request for Submission Complet filed on: 03/13/2026 Extra Text: Order setting hearing filed 03/13/26 |
| Docket Entry Information | |||
| Docket Description | Date Filed | Extra Text | |
| 3696 - Pre-Trial Order | 03/17/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11581631 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-17-2026:11:01:00 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 03/17/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11581633 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-17-2026:11:01:29 | |
| A120 - Exemption from Arbitration | 03/16/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11578339 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-16-2026:10:02:41 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 03/16/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11578342 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-16-2026:10:03:12 | |
| 3242 - Ord Setting Hearing | 03/13/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11575922 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-13-2026:11:53:17 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 03/13/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11575927 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-13-2026:11:54:02 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 03/10/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11568301 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-10-2026:21:09:53 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 03/10/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11568299 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-10-2026:21:03:53 | |
| 3795 - Reply... | 03/10/2026 | Extra Text: DFX: SECURITY LEVEL RAISED ON EXHIBIT 3 DUE TO SSN ON PG 172 & EXHIBIT 4 SSN PG 148 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION AGAINST DEFENDANTS - Transaction 11568298 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-10-2026:21:03:06 | |
| 3860 - Request for Submission | 03/10/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11568300 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-10-2026:21:09:11 DOCUMENT TITLE: PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION PARTY SUBMITTING: RICHARD HASKIN, ESQ. DATE SUBMITTED: 03/10/2026 SUBMITTED BY: AJ DATE RECEIVED JUDGE OFFICE: | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 03/04/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11554599 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-04-2026:12:59:12 | |
| 3840 - Request Exemption Arbitration | 03/04/2026 | Extra Text: JOINT REQUEST FOR EXEMPTION TO ARBITRATION PROGRAM - Transaction 11554440 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-04-2026:12:32:30 | |
| 3860 - Request for Submission | 03/04/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11554596 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-04-2026:12:58:24 DOCUMENT TITLE: JOINT REQUEST FOR EXEMPTION TO ARBITRATION PROGRAM PARTY SUBMITTING: JORGE PADILLA, ESQ. DATE SUBMITTED: 03/04/2026 SUBMITTED BY: AJ DATE RECEIVED JUDGE OFFICE: | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 03/04/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11554446 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-04-2026:12:33:12 | |
| 2650 - Opposition to ... | 03/03/2026 | Extra Text: OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS’ COUNTERMOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION - Transaction 11552237 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 03-03-2026:15:04:16 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 03/03/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11552281 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-03-2026:15:05:11 | |
| 3795 - Reply... | 03/02/2026 | Extra Text: STRICKEN - Transaction 11549548 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-02-2026:15:58:24 | |
| 3795 - Reply... | 03/02/2026 | Extra Text: REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO STRIKE - Transaction 11549624 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-02-2026:16:12:10 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 03/02/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11549559 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-02-2026:16:01:49 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 03/02/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11549609 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-02-2026:16:09:17 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 03/02/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11549630 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-02-2026:16:13:45 | |
| 2589 - Notice of Stricken Document | 03/02/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11549606 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-02-2026:16:08:35 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/26/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11543350 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-26-2026:13:53:55 | |
| 1145 - Answer to Counterclaim-Civil | 02/26/2026 | Extra Text: COUNTERDEFENDANTS’ ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM - Transaction 11543269 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 02-26-2026:13:49:41 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/26/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11543353 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-26-2026:13:55:15 | |
| 2645 - Opposition to Mtn ... | 02/26/2026 | Extra Text: PLAINTIFFS’ OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO STRIKE FUGITIVE DOCUMENT - Transaction 11543282 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 02-26-2026:13:50:48 | |
| 3795 - Reply... | 02/24/2026 | Extra Text: DEFENDANTS’ REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION - Transaction 11534522 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-24-2026:10:10:27 | |
| 3860 - Request for Submission | 02/24/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11535880 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-24-2026:14:26:03 DOCUMENT TITLE: DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION PARTY SUBMITTING: WHITNEY SELERT, ESQ. DATE SUBMITTED: 02/24/2026 SUBMITTED BY: AJ DATE RECEIVED JUDGE OFFICE: | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/24/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11535900 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-24-2026:14:30:07 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/24/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11534531 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-24-2026:10:12:02 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/23/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11532186 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-23-2026:12:29:53 | |
| 2475 - Mtn to Strike... | 02/23/2026 | Extra Text: Motion to Strike Fugitive Document - Transaction 11532159 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-23-2026:12:27:25 | |
| A095 - **Case Stayed Pending Arb | 02/21/2026 | Extra Text: | |
| 2650 - Opposition to ... | 02/19/2026 | Extra Text: PLAINTIFFS’ OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS’ REQUEST FOR SUBMISSION OF DEFENDANTS’ MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION - Transaction 11525401 - Approved By: AJUAREZ : 02-19-2026:10:20:07 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/19/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11525473 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-19-2026:10:20:39 | |
| 3860 - Request for Submission | 02/17/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11520593 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-17-2026:12:42:53 DOCUMENT TITLE: DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION PARTY SUBMITTING: WHITNEY SELERT, ESQ. DATE SUBMITTED: 02/17/2026 SUBMITTED BY: AJ DATE RECEIVED JUDGE OFFICE: | |
| 2645 - Opposition to Mtn ... | 02/17/2026 | Extra Text: PLAINTIFFS’ OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS’ MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION - Transaction 11521795 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 02-17-2026:16:49:21 | |
| 2490 - Motion ... | 02/17/2026 | Extra Text: DFX: EXHIBITS PRESENTED INCORRECTLY - PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION AGAINST DEFENDANTS - Transaction 11521801 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 02-17-2026:16:55:23 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/17/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11521842 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-17-2026:16:56:13 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/17/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11520599 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-17-2026:12:43:46 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/17/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11521803 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-17-2026:16:50:20 | |
| 4047 - Stip Extension of Time ... | 02/11/2026 | Extra Text: STRICKEN Transaction 11510789 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-11-2026:09:47:03 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/11/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11511168 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-11-2026:11:09:02 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/11/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11511068 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-11-2026:10:48:23 | |
| 2589 - Notice of Stricken Document | 02/11/2026 | Extra Text: EXHIBIT IS FILED INCORRECTLY. EXHIBIT SHOULD BE A SEPARATE PDF SCAN, WHICH IS THEN ATTACHED TO THE STIPULATION AS AN EXHIBIT. THEY SHOULD NOT BE FILED TOGETHER AS ONE PDF SCAN. STIPULATION IS ALSO MISSING AN AFFIRMATION - Transaction 11510993 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-11-2026:10:26:21 | |
| 4047 - Stip Extension of Time ... | 02/11/2026 | Extra Text: Stipulation and Order - Transaction 11511166 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-11-2026:11:08:32 | |
| 2589 - Notice of Stricken Document | 02/11/2026 | Extra Text: EXHIBIT IS FILED INCORRECTLY. IT NEEDS TO BE A SEPARATE PDF SCAN, WHICH IS THEN ATTACHED TO THE STIPULATION AS AN EXHIBIT. AFFIRMATION SHOULD BE ATTACHED TO THE LEAD DOCUMENT/STIPULATION, NOT ATTACHED AS THE LAST PAGE OF THE EXHIBIT - Transaction 11511064 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-11-2026:10:47:42 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/11/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11510997 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-11-2026:10:27:00 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/11/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11510795 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-11-2026:09:47:51 | |
| 4047 - Stip Extension of Time ... | 02/11/2026 | Extra Text: STRICKEN Transaction 11511030 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-11-2026:10:39:18 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/11/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11511037 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-11-2026:10:42:15 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/10/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11509837 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-10-2026:15:44:58 | |
| 4047 - Stip Extension of Time ... | 02/10/2026 | Extra Text: STRICKEN - Transaction 11509500 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-10-2026:14:49:48 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/10/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11509525 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-10-2026:14:50:56 | |
| 2589 - Notice of Stricken Document | 02/10/2026 | Extra Text: PROPOSED ORDERS MUST BE ATTACHED AS A CONTINUATION TO A LEAD DOCUMENT IN A SEPARATE PDF- SEE INSTRUCTIONAL VIDEO AT WASHOECOURTS.COM, FORMS AND PACKETS TAB - Transaction 11509830 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-10-2026:15:44:04 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/04/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11497526 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-04-2026:16:11:40 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 02/04/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11497487 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-04-2026:16:05:55 | |
| 3795 - Reply... | 02/04/2026 | Extra Text: Reply ISO Defendants' Club Tahoe, Keith Wilson, Gloria DeAlba, Donald Wall, Mark Pearl, and Robert Vermeltfroort Ex-Parte Motion for an Order Shortening Time for Plaintiffs to Respond to Defendants’ - Transaction 11497472 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-04-2026:16:04:43 | |
| 3860 - Request for Submission | 02/04/2026 | Extra Text: Request for Submission of Ex Parte OST Motion - Transaction 11497506 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-04-2026:16:10:01 DOCUMENT TITLE: Defendants’ Ex Parte Motion for Order Shortening Time for Plaintiff to Respond to Defendants’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction PARTY SUBMITTING: WHITNEY SELERT, ESQ. DATE SUBMITTED: 2/4/26 SUBMITTED BY: NM DATE RECEIVED JUDGE OFFICE: | |
| 2645 - Opposition to Mtn ... | 01/28/2026 | Extra Text: PLAINTIFFS’ OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS’ EX PARTE MOTION FOR ORDER SHORTENING TIME TO RESPOND TO DEFENDANTS’ MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION - Transaction 11482350 - Approved By: AJUAREZ : 01-28-2026:14:42:55 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 01/28/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11482484 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-28-2026:14:44:29 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 01/27/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11479665 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-27-2026:14:21:28 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 01/27/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11479661 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-27-2026:14:19:45 | |
| $DEFT - $Addl Def/Answer - Prty/Appear | 01/27/2026 | Extra Text: ROBERT VERMELTFOORT - Transaction 11479593 - Approved By: AJUAREZ : 01-27-2026:14:18:54 | |
| $DEFT - $Addl Def/Answer - Prty/Appear | 01/27/2026 | Extra Text: MARC PEARL - Transaction 11479593 - Approved By: AJUAREZ : 01-27-2026:14:18:54 | |
| $DEFT - $Addl Def/Answer - Prty/Appear | 01/27/2026 | Extra Text: DONALD WALL - Transaction 11479593 - Approved By: AJUAREZ : 01-27-2026:14:18:54 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 01/27/2026 | Extra Text: Transaction 11479667 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-27-2026:14:21:54 | |
| $DEFT - $Addl Def/Answer - Prty/Appear | 01/27/2026 | Extra Text: KEITH WILSON - Transaction 11479593 - Approved By: AJUAREZ : 01-27-2026:14:18:54 | |
| $1560 - $Def 1st Appearance - CV | 01/27/2026 | Extra Text: CLUB TAHOE RESORT OWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. - Transaction 11479593 - Approved By: AJUAREZ : 01-27-2026:14:18:54 | |
| 2490 - Motion ... | 01/27/2026 | Extra Text: MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION - Transaction 11479605 - Approved By: AJUAREZ : 01-27-2026:14:20:33 | |
| PAYRC - **Payment Receipted | 01/27/2026 | Extra Text: A Payment of $358.00 was made on receipt DCDC792479. | |
| 1137 - Answer and Counterclaim | 01/27/2026 | Extra Text: ANSWER TO AMENDED COMPLAINT - Transaction 11479593 - Approved By: AJUAREZ : 01-27-2026:14:18:54 | |
| $DEFT - $Addl Def/Answer - Prty/Appear | 01/27/2026 | Extra Text: GLORIA DEALBA - Transaction 11479593 - Approved By: AJUAREZ : 01-27-2026:14:18:54 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 12/09/2025 | Extra Text: Transaction 11393271 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-09-2025:08:23:42 | |
| 1090 - Amended Complaint | 12/08/2025 | Extra Text: FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT - Transaction 11392620 - Approved By: AJUAREZ : 12-09-2025:08:22:56 | |
| 1067 - Affidavit/Declaration of Service | 11/03/2025 | Extra Text: BONNIE L. CIBURA OBO CLUB TAHOE RESORT OWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. 10/22/2025 - Transaction 11329946 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 11-03-2025:12:06:19 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 11/03/2025 | Extra Text: Transaction 11329952 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 11-03-2025:12:07:00 | |
| 4090 - ** Summons Issued | 10/03/2025 | Extra Text: Summons - Christina Becker - Transaction 11277324 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 10-03-2025:11:32:57 | |
| 4090 - ** Summons Issued | 10/03/2025 | Extra Text: Summons - Keith Ogden - Transaction 11277324 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 10-03-2025:11:32:57 | |
| 4090 - ** Summons Issued | 10/03/2025 | Extra Text: Summons - Marc Pearl - Transaction 11277324 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 10-03-2025:11:32:57 | |
| 4090 - ** Summons Issued | 10/03/2025 | Extra Text: Summons - Robert Vermeltoort - Transaction 11277324 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 10-03-2025:11:32:57 | |
| 4090 - ** Summons Issued | 10/03/2025 | Extra Text: Summons - Donald Wall - Transaction 11277324 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 10-03-2025:11:32:57 | |
| 4090 - ** Summons Issued | 10/03/2025 | Extra Text: Summons - Gloria Dealba - Transaction 11277324 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 10-03-2025:11:32:57 | |
| 4090 - ** Summons Issued | 10/03/2025 | Extra Text: Summons - Keith Wilson - Transaction 11277324 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 10-03-2025:11:32:57 | |
| 4090 - ** Summons Issued | 10/03/2025 | Extra Text: Summons - Club Tahoe Resort Owners Association, Inc. - Transaction 11277324 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 10-03-2025:11:32:57 | |
| NEF - Proof of Electronic Service | 10/03/2025 | Extra Text: Transaction 11277404 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 10-03-2025:11:33:58 | |
| $1425 - $Complaint - Civil | 09/25/2025 | Extra Text: Complaint - Transaction 11261570 - Approved By: ADIXON : 09-25-2025:16:13:44 | |
| PAYRC - **Payment Receipted | 09/25/2025 | Extra Text: A Payment of $285.00 was made on receipt DCDC782684. | |
| $PLTF - $Addl Plaintiff/Complaint | 09/25/2025 | Extra Text: ROBERT PAYTON - Transaction 11261570 - Approved By: ADIXON : 09-25-2025:16:13:44 | |