Detailed Case Information - FV18-01048

Case Description: FV18-01048 - CUST: JESSE JACOBY VS. MEGAN MARELICH (D11)

Filing Date: 07/06/2018

Case Type: CU - CUSTODY (NON-DIVORCE)

Status: Case Disposed

Printer Friendly Version

Case Parties

Seq No. Type Name
2 PETR - Petitioner JACOBY, JESSE
3 RESP - Respondent MARELICH, MEGAN
7 ATTY - Attorney Hotchkin, Jr., Esq., Lee Thomas

Reference Numbers

No Cross Reference Numbers Available

Event Information

Date/Time Hearing Judge Event Description Outcome
1. 01/08/2021 at 8:37 AM Honorable CYNTHIA LU S1 - Request for Submission
S200 - Request for Submission Complet filed on: 01/08/2021
Extra Text:
2. 07/16/2020 at 3:30 PM Honorable PAIGE DOLLINGER H788 - REVIEW HEARING
- filed on:
Extra Text:
3. 04/01/2020 at 9:00 AM Honorable PAIGE DOLLINGER H788 - REVIEW HEARING
D843 - Vacated-to be reset filed on: 03/24/2020
Extra Text: TO BE RESET - COVID
4. 01/16/2020 at 5:34 PM Honorable PAIGE DOLLINGER S1 - Request for Submission
S200 - Request for Submission Complet filed on: 01/21/2020
Extra Text:
5. 12/10/2019 at 9:00 AM Honorable PAIGE DOLLINGER H788 - REVIEW HEARING
D435 - Heard ... filed on: 12/10/2019
Extra Text: j.hogen, clerk, ctrm11; review hearing set
6. 02/05/2019 at 9:00 AM Honorable PAIGE DOLLINGER H844 - TRIAL - NON JURY
D845 - Vacated filed on: 12/17/2018
Extra Text:
7. 01/09/2019 at 4:53 PM Honorable PAIGE DOLLINGER S1 - Request for Submission
S200 - Request for Submission Complet filed on: 01/22/2019
Extra Text:
8. 12/17/2018 at 1:30 PM Honorable PAIGE DOLLINGER H812 - SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE
D495 - Heard-Settled filed on: 12/17/2018
Extra Text: J.MCKAY/JAVS (DEPT. 11) ORDER ENTERED. COUNSEL MILLER TO PREPARE ORDER.
9. 10/09/2018 at 10:30 AM Honorable PAIGE DOLLINGER H185 - CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE
D435 - Heard ... filed on: 10/09/2018
Extra Text: JAVS. DEPARTMENT 11. R. WILDING, CLERK. CLERK TO PREPARE ORDER SETTING SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE AND TRIAL. CLERK TO PREPARE PRE-TRIAL ORDER.

Docket Entry Information

Docket Description Date Filed Extra Text
1. PAYRC - **Payment Receipted 01/08/2021 Extra Text: A Payment of $25.00 was made on receipt DCFC85975.
2. F275 - Bench N/J/T Judgment Reached 01/08/2021 Extra Text:
3. 3860 - Request for Submission 01/08/2021 Extra Text: - Transaction 8236930 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 01-08-2021:09:31:54 DOCUMENT TITLE: EX PARTE EMERGENCY MOTION REGARDING CHILDREN PARTY SUBMITTING: MEGAN MARELICH DATE SUBMITTED: 1/08/2021 SUBMITTED BY: CS DATE RECEIVED JUDGE OFFICE:
4. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/08/2021 Extra Text: Transaction 8237067 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-08-2021:09:33:17
5. 1675 - Ex-Parte Ord... 01/08/2021 Extra Text: ORDER DENYING EX PARTE MOTION - Transaction 8238133 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-08-2021:14:48:28
6. $1985 - **$Motion/Opposition Notice 01/08/2021 Extra Text: MEGAN MARELICH - Transaction 8236930 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 01-08-2021:09:31:54
7. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/08/2021 Extra Text: Transaction 8238137 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-08-2021:14:49:29
8. 1325 - ** Case Reopened 01/08/2021 Extra Text:
9. 2590 - Notice Withdrawal of Attorney 11/02/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 8142096 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 11-02-2020:11:41:21
10. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 11/02/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 8142104 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 11-02-2020:11:42:19
11. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 10/05/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 8100728 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 10-05-2020:15:13:38
12. 1696 - Hrg Exhibits Maintnd in File 10/05/2020 Extra Text: 07-16-20 HRG - Transaction 8100724 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 10-05-2020:15:12:37
13. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 08/31/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 8045376 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-31-2020:13:52:17
14. 1930 - Letters ... 08/31/2020 Extra Text: LETTERS Transaction 8045369 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-31-2020:13:51:15
15. 1368 - Certificate ... 08/24/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 8034580 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-24-2020:15:41:21
16. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 08/24/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 8034590 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-24-2020:15:42:26
17. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 08/12/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 8015660 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-12-2020:13:57:15
18. 3790 - Reply to/in Opposition 08/12/2020 Extra Text: REPLY TO OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION OF ORDER AFTER HEARING - Transaction 8015640 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 08-12-2020:13:56:16
19. 2700 - Ord After Hearing... 08/11/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 8014502 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-11-2020:21:04:08
20. 2540 - Notice of Entry of Ord 08/11/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 8014513 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-11-2020:21:22:07
21. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 08/11/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 8014504 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-11-2020:21:05:07
22. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 08/11/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 8014514 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-11-2020:21:23:07
23. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 08/05/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 8005351 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-05-2020:15:57:28
24. 2645 - Opposition to Mtn ... 08/05/2020 Extra Text: OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION OF ORDER AFTER HEARING - Transaction 8005338 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 08-05-2020:15:56:24
25. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/22/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7983916 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-22-2020:15:55:11
26. 2490 - Motion ... 07/22/2020 Extra Text: DFX: MISSING INDEX OF EXHIBITS MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION OF ORDER AFTER HEARING - Transaction 7983823 - Approved By: SACORDAG : 07-22-2020:15:54:10
27. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/17/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7977278 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-17-2020:15:35:17
28. MIN - ***Minutes 07/17/2020 Extra Text: 07-16-20 REVIEW HEARING - Transaction 7977273 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-17-2020:15:34:16
29. 1650 - Errata... 07/16/2020 Extra Text: ERRATA TO RESPONDENT’S HEARING STATEMENT - Transaction 7974291 - Approved By: SACORDAG : 07-16-2020:12:35:42
30. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/16/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7974131 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-16-2020:11:49:50
31. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/16/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7974306 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-16-2020:12:36:30
32. 4105 - Supplemental ... 07/16/2020 Extra Text: SUPPLEMENT TO RESPONDENT’S HEARING STATEMENT - Transaction 7974127 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-16-2020:11:49:01
33. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/10/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7964325 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-10-2020:07:43:54
34. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/10/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7964650 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-10-2020:09:56:46
35. 1650 - Errata... 07/10/2020 Extra Text: ERRATA TO RESPONDENT’S HEARING STATEMENT - Transaction 7964641 - Approved By: SACORDAG : 07-10-2020:09:55:52
36. 2610 - Notice ... 07/09/2020 Extra Text: NOTICE OF CONCURRENT PROCEEDING - Transaction 7962507 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 07-09-2020:10:34:08
37. 2550 - Notice of Hearing 07/09/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7962454 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-09-2020:10:16:32
38. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/09/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7962464 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-09-2020:10:17:41
39. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/09/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7962518 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-09-2020:10:35:12
40. 3975 - Statement ... 07/09/2020 Extra Text: RESPONDENT’S HEARING STATEMENT - Transaction 7964138 - Approved By: SACORDAG : 07-10-2020:07:41:39
41. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/29/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7946801 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-29-2020:11:21:09
42. 1020 - Addendum 06/29/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7946797 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-29-2020:11:20:08
43. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/08/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7914600 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-08-2020:16:26:03
44. 3975 - Statement ... 06/08/2020 Extra Text: STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANT ISSUES STILL IN DISPUTE - Transaction 7913776 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 06-08-2020:14:01:58
45. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/08/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7913831 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-08-2020:14:02:56
46. 2550 - Notice of Hearing 06/08/2020 Extra Text: NOTICE OF RESET REVIEW HEARING - Transaction 7914594 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-08-2020:16:25:06
47. 2610 - Notice ... 03/26/2020 Extra Text: NOTICE OF VACATED HEARING 4/1/20 0900 - Transaction 7810513 - Approved By: JBYE : 03-26-2020:10:35:48
48. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/26/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7810655 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-26-2020:10:38:21
49. 2700 - Ord After Hearing... 01/21/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7695879 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-21-2020:14:33:13
50. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/21/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7695884 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-21-2020:14:34:22
51. 3860 - Request for Submission 01/16/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7691455 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-16-2020:17:34:49 DOCUMENT TITLE: ORDER AFTER HEARING (ORDER ATTACHED) PARTY SUBMITTING: KAITLYN MILLER, ESQ. DATE SUBMITTED: 1/16/2020 SUBMITTED BY: DHOERTH DATE RECEIVED JUDGE OFFICE:
52. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/16/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7691458 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-16-2020:17:35:48
53. MIN - ***Minutes 12/19/2019 Extra Text: 12/10/19 REVIEW - Transaction 7648729 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-19-2019:16:35:28
54. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/19/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7648734 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-19-2019:16:36:33
55. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/10/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7629397 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-10-2019:11:40:22
56. 3835 - Report... 12/10/2019 Extra Text: RESPONDENT'S EXHIBIT 1 - Transaction 7629384 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-10-2019:11:37:00
57. 2610 - Notice ... 12/06/2019 Extra Text: NOTICE CORRECTING SCRIVENER'S ERROR - Transaction 7623561 - Approved By: DHOERTH : 12-06-2019:09:30:55
58. 2610 - Notice ... 12/06/2019 Extra Text: NOTICE CORRECTING SCRIVENER'S ERROR - Transaction 7623530 - Approved By: SBLAKE : 12-06-2019:09:05:59
59. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/06/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7623538 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-06-2019:09:07:00
60. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/06/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7623608 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-06-2019:09:31:58
61. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/05/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7622335 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-05-2019:14:07:58
62. 2520 - Notice of Appearance 12/05/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7622304 - Approved By: DHOERTH : 12-05-2019:14:06:54
63. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/03/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7616359 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-03-2019:11:18:48
64. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/03/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7616708 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-03-2019:12:31:52
65. 4055 - Subpoena 12/03/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7616275 - Approved By: DHOERTH : 12-03-2019:11:16:07
66. 4055 - Subpoena 12/03/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7616686 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-03-2019:12:29:34
67. 2520 - Notice of Appearance 12/03/2019 Extra Text: KAITLYN MILLER, ESQ. FOR MEGAN MARELICH - Transaction 7616275 - Approved By: DHOERTH : 12-03-2019:11:16:07
68. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 04/30/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7244826 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 04-30-2019:12:28:28
69. 3835 - Report... 04/30/2019 Extra Text: TAX FORMS FOR 2017 & 2018 - Transaction 7244818 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 04-30-2019:12:27:35
70. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 02/04/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7100541 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-04-2019:13:15:13
71. 2590 - Notice Withdrawal of Attorney 02/04/2019 Extra Text: NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF ATTORNEY: RICHARD P. DAVIES ESQ / PETR JESSE JACOBY - Transaction 7100372 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 02-04-2019:13:14:17
72. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/31/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7096824 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-31-2019:16:35:05
73. 2590 - Notice Withdrawal of Attorney 01/31/2019 Extra Text: NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF COUNSEL: KAITLYN A MILLER ESQ / RESP MEGAN MARELICH - Transaction 7096503 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 01-31-2019:16:33:53
74. 2540 - Notice of Entry of Ord 01/31/2019 Extra Text: NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER - Transaction 7096503 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 01-31-2019:16:33:53
75. 2867 - Ord Estab Cust/Visitation... 01/22/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7079566 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-22-2019:16:30:27
76. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/22/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7079575 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-22-2019:16:31:32
77. F255 - Setld/Withdrn with Jud Conf/Hg 01/22/2019 Extra Text:
78. 3860 - Request for Submission 01/09/2019 Extra Text: REQUEST FOR SUBMISSION - Transaction 7059969 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 01-09-2019:16:52:21 DOCUMENT TITLE: ORDER ESTABLISHING CUSTODY, VISITATION AND SUPPORT PARTY SUBMITTING: KAITLYN A MILLER ESQ DATE SUBMITTED: 1-9-19 SUBMITTED BY: YV DATE RECEIVED JUDGE OFFICE:
79. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/09/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7060137 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-09-2019:16:53:35
80. MIN - ***Minutes 12/18/2018 Extra Text: 12-17-18 SC - Transaction 7028897 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-18-2018:09:53:24
81. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/18/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 7028905 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-18-2018:09:54:24
82. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/14/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 7025609 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-14-2018:14:32:14
83. 3935 - Settlement Conference Statemnt 12/14/2018 Extra Text: RESPONDENT’S SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT - Transaction 7025498 - Approved By: PMSEWELL : 12-14-2018:14:30:14
84. 3935 - Settlement Conference Statemnt 12/14/2018 Extra Text: PETITIONERS SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT - Transaction 7025883 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 12-14-2018:16:42:39
85. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/14/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 7026007 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-14-2018:16:43:42
86. 3897 - Return 12/04/2018 Extra Text: RETURNED MAIL - Transaction 7007043 - Approved By: NMASON : 12-04-2018:16:14:44
87. 3897 - Return 12/04/2018 Extra Text: RETURNED MAIL - Transaction 7007040 - Approved By: NMASON : 12-04-2018:16:14:53
88. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/04/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 7007098 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-04-2018:16:16:10
89. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/04/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 7007100 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-04-2018:16:16:11
90. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 11/07/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6966451 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 11-07-2018:13:27:51
91. 2520 - Notice of Appearance 11/07/2018 Extra Text: RICHARD P. DAVIES ESQ / PETR JESSE JACOBY - Transaction 6966290 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 11-07-2018:13:26:58
92. MIN - ***Minutes 10/10/2018 Extra Text: CMC 10/9/18 - Transaction 6920318 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 10-10-2018:10:53:40
93. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 10/10/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6922002 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 10-10-2018:16:46:43
94. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 10/10/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6920324 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 10-10-2018:10:54:44
95. 3370 - Order ... 10/10/2018 Extra Text: ORDER SETTING SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE; ORDER SETTING TRIAL - Transaction 6921983 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 10-10-2018:16:42:56
96. 3696 - Pre-Trial Order 10/10/2018 Extra Text: ORDER REGARDING PRETRIAL PROCEDURE - Transaction 6921992 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 10-10-2018:16:44:04
97. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 10/10/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6922022 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 10-10-2018:16:49:12
98. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 10/09/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6918349 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 10-09-2018:12:23:11
99. 4105 - Supplemental ... 10/09/2018 Extra Text: Supporting documentation in response to counterclaim exhibits 11-14 - Transaction 6918346 - Approved By: PMSEWELL : 10-09-2018:12:22:09
100. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 10/03/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6910305 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 10-03-2018:16:18:09
101. 3975 - Statement ... 10/03/2018 Extra Text: RESPONDENTS CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT - Transaction 6910290 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 10-03-2018:16:17:20
102. 3795 - Reply... 09/27/2018 Extra Text:
103. 1740 - Financial Declaration ... 08/28/2018 Extra Text: MEGAN MARELICH - Transaction 6851837 - Approved By: PMSEWELL : 08-28-2018:11:08:05
104. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 08/28/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6851959 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-28-2018:11:09:44
105. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 08/15/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6829746 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-15-2018:08:56:07
106. PAYRC - **Payment Receipted 08/15/2018 Extra Text: A Payment of $213.00 was made on receipt DCFC79931.
107. 4105 - Supplemental ... 08/15/2018 Extra Text: SUPPLEMENTAL ANSWER AND COUNTERCLAIM - Transaction 6830295 - Approved By: CVERA : 08-15-2018:13:21:04
108. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 08/15/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6830482 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-15-2018:13:22:14
109. 1137 - Answer and Counterclaim 08/14/2018 Extra Text: ANSWER AND COUNTERCLAIM TO PETITION TO ESTABLISH CUSTODY, SUPPORT AND VISITATION - Transaction 6829582 - Approved By: CVERA : 08-15-2018:08:54:58
110. $1560 - $Def 1st Appearance - CV 08/14/2018 Extra Text: MEGAN MARELICH - Transaction 6829582 - Approved By: CVERA : 08-15-2018:08:54:58
111. 4085 - Summons Filed 07/30/2018 Extra Text: MEGAN JONES - 7/26/2018
112. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/27/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6799448 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-27-2018:11:02:59
113. 2523E - Notice of Case Mgt Conference 07/27/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6799440 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-27-2018:11:01:53
114. FCIS - Family Court Info Sheet 07/06/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6764334 - Approved By: KJONES : 07-06-2018:15:01:52
115. 1740 - Financial Declaration ... 07/06/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6764334 - Approved By: KJONES : 07-06-2018:15:01:52
116. PAYRC - **Payment Receipted 07/06/2018 Extra Text: A Payment of -$260.00 was made on receipt DCDC613906.
117. $3609 - $Pet/Est Custody & Visitation 07/06/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6764334 - Approved By: KJONES : 07-06-2018:15:01:52
118. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/06/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6764361 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-06-2018:15:03:22
The District Court is comprised of 16 departments. Each Judge sits in a differently numbered Department. When a Judge leaves service, the new Judge's name replaces the former Judge's name on all matters pending and previously closed in that department. This change will not reflect that a previous sitting Judge presided over a matter.