Please fill out at least one field before submitting this form.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Detailed Case Information - CR17-0304

Case Description: CR17-0304 - STATE VS. BRANDON NICHOLAS MCGASKEY (D4)

Filing Date: 02/27/2017

Case Type: CR - CRIMINAL

Status: Case Disposed

Printer Friendly Version

Case Parties - Click to expand

Case Parties

Seq No. Type Name
2 DEFT - Defendant MCGASKEY, BRANDON NICHOLAS
3 PD - Public Defender Leslie, Esq., James B.
6 PLTF - Plaintiff STATE OF NEVADA,
7 PNP - Parole & Probation Parole & Probation, Div. of
8 JUDG - Judge STEINHEIMER, CONNIE J.
11 PD - Public Defender Meyer, Esq., Emilie
13 DA - District Attorney Kossow, Esq., Kelly Ann

Cross Reference Number(s) - Click to expand

Reference Numbers

Reference Number
1. DA1614337
2. PCNRPD0013757C
3. PCNRPD1507212C
4. RCR2016089251A
5. RPDRP16021129

Event Information - Click to expand

Event Information

Date/Time Hearing Judge Event Description Outcome
1. 02/11/2020 at 9:00 AM Honorable CONNIE STEINHEIMER H604 - MOTION -PROBATION REVOCATION
D730 - Probation Revoked filed on: 02/11/2020
Extra Text:
2. 01/21/2020 at 10:00 AM Honorable CONNIE STEINHEIMER H604 - MOTION -PROBATION REVOCATION
D870 - Vacated - Stipulation & Ord filed on: 01/17/2020
Extra Text:
3. 12/12/2019 at 9:00 AM Honorable CONNIE STEINHEIMER H604 - MOTION -PROBATION REVOCATION
D870 - Vacated - Stipulation & Ord filed on: 12/11/2019
Extra Text:
4. 07/18/2019 at 9:00 AM Honorable CONNIE STEINHEIMER H604 - MOTION -PROBATION REVOCATION
D735 - Reinstated on Probation filed on: 07/18/2019
Extra Text: ADDED CONDITIONS: (1) 1 DAY OF COMM SVC PER MONTH UNTIL NO LONGER REQUIRED PER PROB OFC; (2) 30 DAYS OF HOUSE ARREST, TO BE INSTALLED WITHIN 4 DAYS OF RELEASE FROM CUSTODY
5. 06/27/2019 at 9:00 AM Honorable CONNIE STEINHEIMER H604 - MOTION -PROBATION REVOCATION
D455 - Heard-Continued Defendant filed on: 06/27/2019
Extra Text: CONTINUED FOR THE DIVISION OF PAROLE AND PROBATION TO CONFIRM RESIDENCE, PERSONS LIVING IN RESIDENCE AND POSSIBLE TREATMENT PLAN
6. 05/28/2019 at 9:00 AM Honorable CONNIE STEINHEIMER H604 - MOTION -PROBATION REVOCATION
D455 - Heard-Continued Defendant filed on: 05/28/2019
Extra Text: TO RESOLVE NEW CHARGES
7. 06/13/2017 at 9:00 AM Honorable CONNIE STEINHEIMER H808 - SENTENCING
D765 - Sentenced filed on: 06/13/2017
Extra Text:
8. 04/27/2017 at 9:00 AM Honorable CONNIE STEINHEIMER H576 - MOTION TO SET TRIAL
D655 - Pled Guilty filed on: 04/27/2017
Extra Text: COUNTS I AND II OF THE AMENDED INFORMATION
9. 04/25/2017 at 9:00 AM Honorable CONNIE STEINHEIMER H160 - ARRAIGNMENT
D725 - Pled Not Guilty filed on: 04/25/2017
Extra Text: INFORMATION BASED ON THE DEFT'S HESITATION WITH TRIAL DATE - MTN TO SET TRIAL SET COURT FOUND THAT NO CONFLICT EXISTS WITH COUNSEL BRANZELL REPRESENTING DEFENDANT
10. 04/13/2017 at 9:00 AM Honorable CONNIE STEINHEIMER H160 - ARRAIGNMENT
D870 - Vacated - Stipulation & Ord filed on: 04/12/2017
Extra Text:
11. 04/04/2017 at 9:00 AM Honorable CONNIE STEINHEIMER H160 - ARRAIGNMENT
D455 - Heard-Continued Defendant filed on: 04/04/2017
Extra Text: CONTINUED FOR DEFENSE COUNSEL TO FURTHER REVIEW THE DISCOVERY WITH THE DEFENDANT - OVER OBJECTION BY THE STATE
12. 03/14/2017 at 9:00 AM Honorable CONNIE STEINHEIMER H160 - ARRAIGNMENT
D455 - Heard-Continued Defendant filed on: 03/14/2017
Extra Text: CONTINUED FOR FURTHER NEGOTIATIONS MOTION FOR BAIL REDUCTION AND/OR RE-INTERVIEW BY PRE-TRIAL SERVICES DENIED

Docket Entry Information - Click to expand

Docket Entry Information

Docket Description Date Filed Extra Text
1. PAYRC - **Payment Receipted 10/20/2022 Extra Text: A Payment of -$.02 was made on receipt DCDC703194.
2. PAYRC - **Payment Receipted 10/14/2022 Extra Text: A Payment of -$.04 was made on receipt DCDC702588.
3. PAYRC - **Payment Receipted 09/14/2022 Extra Text: A Payment of -$19.07 was made on receipt DCDC699439.
4. PAYRC - **Payment Receipted 08/03/2022 Extra Text: A Payment of -$53.32 was made on receipt DCDC695855.
5. 3370 - Order ... 02/25/2022 Extra Text: ORDER REGARDING MOTION FOR TRANSCRIPTS AT PUBLIC EXPENSE - IF DEFENDANT STILL WISHES TO PURSUE MOTION, MUST SERVE AND FORMALLY SUBMIT - Transaction 8915838 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-25-2022:10:53:14
6. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 02/25/2022 Extra Text: Transaction 8915854 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-25-2022:10:54:24
7. 2230 - Mtn Trial Trans. Public Exp 10/15/2021 Extra Text: MOTION FOR TRANSCRIPTS AT STATE EXPENSE
8. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 04/10/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7829688 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 04-10-2020:09:42:31
9. 3210 - Ord Revoking Probation 04/10/2020 Extra Text: (CORRECTED) - Transaction 7829678 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 04-10-2020:09:40:59 4/17/2020 Certified Copies of Corrected Order Revoking Probation and JOC with accompanying documentation to WCJ via interoffice mail. (mdc)
10. MIN - ***Minutes 02/20/2020 Extra Text: MOTION FOR REVOCATION OF PROBATION - 2/11/2020 - Transaction 7750238 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-20-2020:11:53:41
11. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 02/20/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7750260 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-20-2020:11:55:48
12. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 02/11/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7735431 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-11-2020:17:05:34
13. 3210 - Ord Revoking Probation 02/11/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7735428 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-11-2020:17:04:37
14. 3020 - Ord Granting Continuance 01/21/2020 Extra Text: PROBATION REVOCATION FROM 01/21/2020 TO 02/11/2020 AT 0900 - Transaction 7696637 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-21-2020:16:47:47
15. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/21/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7696651 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-21-2020:16:49:44
16. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 01/17/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7693267 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-17-2020:15:05:53
17. 4045 - Stipulation to Continuance 01/17/2020 Extra Text: Transaction 7693262 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 01-17-2020:15:04:54
18. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/12/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7635136 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-12-2019:12:35:54
19. 3020 - Ord Granting Continuance 12/12/2019 Extra Text: - PROBATION REVOCATION HEARING CONTINUED FROM 12/12/19 TO 1/21/20 AT 9:00 A.M. - Transaction 7635131 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-12-2019:12:34:44
20. 4045 - Stipulation to Continuance 12/11/2019 Extra Text: STIPULATION TO CONTINUE - Transaction 7633164 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-11-2019:15:33:19
21. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/11/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7633187 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-11-2019:15:36:16
22. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/06/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7623628 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-06-2019:09:37:03
23. 1250 - Application for Setting 12/06/2019 Extra Text: APPLICATION FOR SETTING - PROBATION VIOLATION - DECEMBER 12, 2019, 9:00 AM - Transaction 7623622 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-06-2019:09:36:03
24. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 12/05/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7623227 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-05-2019:17:11:52
25. 3702 - Probation Violation Report 12/05/2019 Extra Text: VIOLATION REPORT - Transaction 7623225 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 12-05-2019:17:10:52
26. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 09/18/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7492039 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 09-18-2019:16:17:36
27. 1015 - Acknowledgment of Receipt 09/18/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7492025 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 09-18-2019:16:15:30
28. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 09/11/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7479666 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 09-11-2019:16:04:22
29. 4185 - Transcript 09/11/2019 Extra Text: Motion for Probation Revocation - July 18, 2019 - Transaction 7479642 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 09-11-2019:16:01:53
30. 4185 - Transcript 08/21/2019 Extra Text: Revocation - 6-27-19 - Transaction 7442749 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-21-2019:14:50:18
31. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 08/21/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7442755 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-21-2019:14:51:17
32. MIN - ***Minutes 07/22/2019 Extra Text: PROBATION REVOCATION HEARING 07/18/2019 - Transaction 7386078 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-22-2019:14:20:17
33. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/22/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7386094 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-22-2019:14:21:56
34. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/18/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7381804 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-18-2019:16:25:38
35. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/18/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7381802 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-18-2019:16:25:38
36. 3345 - Ord Reinstate Probation 07/18/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7381796 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-18-2019:16:24:22
37. 2670 - Ord Admit Deft Prob w/Terms 07/18/2019 Extra Text: AMENDED ORDER ADMITTING DEFENDANT TO PROBATION AND FIXING THE TERMS THEREOF - Transaction 7381798 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-18-2019:16:24:23
38. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/03/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7356255 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-03-2019:16:53:52
39. MIN - ***Minutes 07/03/2019 Extra Text: CONTINUED MOTION FOR REVOCATION OF PROBATION - 6/27/19 - Transaction 7356204 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-03-2019:16:44:23
40. MIN - ***Minutes 05/28/2019 Extra Text: MOTION FOR REVOCATION OF PROBATION - 5/28/19 - Transaction 7291401 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-28-2019:16:49:04
41. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 05/28/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7291410 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-28-2019:16:50:13
42. 4075 - Substitution of Counsel 05/23/2019 Extra Text: EMILIE MEYER, Deputy Public Defender - Transaction 7285664 - Approved By: SHIGGINB : 05-23-2019:12:46:37
43. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 05/23/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7285849 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-23-2019:12:47:35
44. 1250 - Application for Setting 05/22/2019 Extra Text: PROBATION VIOLATION -May 28, 2019, at 9:00 AM - Transaction 7283695 - Approved By: SHIGGINB : 05-22-2019:15:13:53
45. 2610 - Notice ... 05/22/2019 Extra Text: NOTICE OF RESPONSIBLE ATTORNEY FOR THE STATE - TYSON LEAGUE DA - Transaction 7283514 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 05-22-2019:15:11:53
46. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 05/22/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7283725 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-22-2019:15:13:57
47. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 05/22/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7283743 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-22-2019:15:16:02
48. 3702 - Probation Violation Report 05/20/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7278243 - Approved By: NMASON : 05-20-2019:11:43:13
49. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 05/20/2019 Extra Text: Transaction 7278262 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-20-2019:11:45:48
50. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 08/15/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6829852 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-15-2018:09:32:23
51. 2670 - Ord Admit Deft Prob w/Terms 08/15/2018 Extra Text: MODIFIED ORDER ADMITTING DEFENDANT TO PROBATION AND FIXING THE TERMS THEREOF - Transaction 6829840 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-15-2018:09:30:55
52. 1970 - Modification Ord - Probation 08/09/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6821579 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-09-2018:13:28:17
53. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 08/09/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6821583 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 08-09-2018:13:29:17
54. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/27/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6799714 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-27-2018:11:56:01
55. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 07/27/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6799705 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 07-27-2018:11:54:48
56. 4270 - Waiver of Appearance 07/27/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6799646 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 07-27-2018:11:53:33
57. 3699 - Probation Incident Report 07/27/2018 Extra Text: Transaction 6799653 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 07-27-2018:11:54:47
58. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 11/13/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6392588 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 11-13-2017:16:11:34
59. MIN - ***Minutes 11/13/2017 Extra Text: SENTENCING - 6/13/17 - Transaction 6392581 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 11-13-2017:16:10:32
60. 4185 - Transcript 06/29/2017 Extra Text: Sentencing - 6-13-17 - Transaction 6172882 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-29-2017:11:44:53
61. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/29/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6172884 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-29-2017:11:45:54
62. 1860 - Judgment Conviction-Corrected 06/20/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6158093 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-20-2017:15:44:31
63. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/20/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6158096 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-20-2017:15:45:18
64. 1850 - Judgment of Conviction 06/13/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6147008 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-13-2017:16:36:25
65. 2670 - Ord Admit Deft Prob w/Terms 06/13/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6147011 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-13-2017:16:36:26
66. COLL - Sent to Collections 06/13/2017 Extra Text: 13-JUN-2017
67. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/13/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6147022 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-13-2017:16:37:30
68. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/13/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6147024 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-13-2017:16:37:32
69. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/08/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6140275 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-08-2017:15:59:04
70. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/08/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6140201 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-08-2017:15:46:40
71. MIN - ***Minutes 06/08/2017 Extra Text: MOTION TO SET TRIAL/ARRAIGNMENT ON AMENDED INFORMATION - 4/27/17 - Transaction 6140268 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-08-2017:15:58:04
72. MIN - ***Minutes 06/08/2017 Extra Text: CONTINUED ARRAIGNMENT - 4/25/17 - Transaction 6140194 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-08-2017:15:45:42
73. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/07/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6137025 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-07-2017:13:01:46
74. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/07/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6138107 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-07-2017:16:59:04
75. MIN - ***Minutes 06/07/2017 Extra Text: CONTINUED ARRAIGNMENT - 4/4/17 - Transaction 6138100 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-07-2017:16:58:01
76. MIN - ***Minutes 06/07/2017 Extra Text: ARRAIGNMENT - 3/14/17 - Transaction 6137016 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-07-2017:13:00:44
77. 4185 - Transcript 06/01/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6127194 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-01-2017:11:42:10
78. 4185 - Transcript 06/01/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6127318 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-01-2017:12:07:43
79. 4185 - Transcript 06/01/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6127289 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-01-2017:12:01:13
80. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/01/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6127197 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-01-2017:11:43:00
81. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/01/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6127292 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-01-2017:12:02:03
82. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 06/01/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6127324 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 06-01-2017:12:08:34
83. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 05/31/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6124022 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-31-2017:08:15:46
84. 4500 - PSI - Confidential 05/30/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6123721 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 05-31-2017:08:14:46
85. 4185 - Transcript 05/08/2017 Extra Text: Motion to Set Trial - 4-27-17 - Transaction 6089030 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-08-2017:11:42:35
86. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 05/08/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6089038 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 05-08-2017:11:43:24
87. 1785 - Guilty Plea Memo/Agreement 04/27/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6073643 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 04-27-2017:15:59:25
88. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 04/27/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6073644 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 04-27-2017:16:00:26
89. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 04/26/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6071820 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 04-26-2017:16:45:04
90. 1095 - Amended Information 04/26/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6071799 - Approved By: MCHOLICO : 04-26-2017:16:42:17 (DOCUMENT MODIFIED TO REFLECT THE DEFENDANT'S TRUE NAME)
91. 1960 - Memorandum ... 04/14/2017 Extra Text: Memorandum of Law Re: Client Complaint and Reported Conflicts of Interest - Transaction 6053021 - Approved By: YVILORIA : 04-14-2017:16:02:53
92. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 04/14/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6053094 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 04-14-2017:16:03:55
93. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 04/12/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 6048593 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 04-12-2017:16:50:54
94. 1250 - Application for Setting 04/12/2017 Extra Text: ARRAIGNMENT 4/25/17 @9:00 - Transaction 6048554 - Approved By: CSULEZIC : 04-12-2017:16:49:50
95. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/08/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5985511 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-08-2017:09:19:51
96. 3700 - Proceedings 03/08/2017 Extra Text: PRELIMINARY HEARING - FEBRUARY 27, 2017 - Transaction 5985293 - Approved By: TBRITTON : 03-08-2017:09:18:38
97. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/07/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5983752 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-07-2017:11:53:14
98. 1800 - Information 03/07/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5983650 - Approved By: MCHOLICO : 03-07-2017:11:52:16 (DOCUMENT MODIFIED TO REFLECT THE DEFENDANT'S TRUE NAME)
99. COC - Evidence Chain of Custody Form 03/02/2017 Extra Text:
100. 1695 - ** Exhibit(s) ... 03/02/2017 Extra Text: RJC State's Exhibit B in evidence room
101. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 03/02/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5975983 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 03-02-2017:09:21:50
102. 4105 - Supplemental ... 03/02/2017 Extra Text: SUPPLEMENTAL PROCEEDINGS - Transaction 5975971 - Approved By: BBLOUGH : 03-02-2017:09:20:32 (RJC State's Exhibit B)
103. 1491 - Pretrl Srvcs Assessment Report 02/28/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5970222 - Approved By: MCHOLICO : 02-28-2017:08:39:39
104. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 02/28/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5970366 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-28-2017:08:40:46
105. NEF - Proof of Electronic Service 02/27/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5969942 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-27-2017:16:25:54
106. 3700 - Proceedings 02/27/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5969706 - Approved By: MCHOLICO : 02-27-2017:15:54:39
107. 2522 - Notice of Bindover 02/27/2017 Extra Text: Transaction 5969706 - Approved By: MCHOLICO : 02-27-2017:15:54:39
108. 1250E - Application for Setting eFile 02/27/2017 Extra Text: 03/14/17 @ 9AM ARRAIGNMENT - Transaction 5969934 - Approved By: NOREVIEW : 02-27-2017:16:24:38
The District Court is comprised of 16 departments. Each Judge sits in a differently numbered Department. When a Judge leaves service, the new Judge's name replaces the former Judge's name on all matters pending and previously closed in that department. This change will not reflect that a previous sitting Judge presided over a matter.